Editing Herzing Issues: Student Organizations and Governance (section)

=== HU-056: SNA inaugural board meeting conducted without faculty advisor; quorum deficiency may require ratification of all initial votes ===
{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%"
! style="width:14em" | Severity
| Medium
! Status
| POSSIBLE
|-
! Issue type
| Governance Validity Question, Quorum Deficiency
! Date added
| 2026-05-04
|-
! Owner
| colspan="3" | SNA Board / Faculty Advisor / Academic Affairs
|}
'''Finding.''' According to the tracker, the SNA inaugural board meeting (April 2026) was conducted without the faculty advisor present. Per Chapter Bylaws Article V Section 2, quorum for board meetings requires the president or vice president, two other board members, and one faculty advisor. Dr. Prashad raised concern about meetings held without faculty advisor. As a result, all votes taken at that meeting, including appointment of Student A, approval of Student B's honor cord, and appointment of the reporting student as delegate, may require re-validation.

'''Evidence.''' SNA Teams email chain (late April / early May 2026): the reporting student raised governance questions. HOSNA Chapter Bylaws Article V Section 2 states that a quorum for the board meetings shall be the president or vice president, two other board members, and one faculty advisor. Dr. Prashad raised concern about meetings held without the faculty advisor present. Source group: SNA Board Leadership Microsoft Teams Chat; SNA Email Chain (Apr to May 2026); HOSNA Chapter Bylaws (2026); SNA Membership Roster (June 2025); NSNA Shared Governance Document (2024); SNA Transition Letter (Student B).

'''Reported statement.''' <blockquote>Are we invalidating all actions taken at our last meeting? We would need to revote on Student A, revote on Student B and Leadership U appointment, revote on my delegate appointment. Do we need to revote everything? My understanding is that you need to be present for a quorum, but the votes would not change.</blockquote> (the reporting student.)

'''Standards.''' HOSNA Chapter Bylaws Article V, Section 2 (Quorum); Robert's Rules of Order (12th ed.) Chapter 40 (Quorum): actions taken without quorum are null and void and require ratification at a meeting where quorum is achieved.

'''Impact.''' If all initial SNA board votes are invalidated, Student B's honor cord recommendation, Student A's appointment, and the reporting student's delegate appointment are all in question. This delays SNA operations and potentially prevents Student B from receiving her graduation honor cord.

'''Notes.''' The quorum deficiency was caused by the faculty advisor's non-responsiveness ({{HU|HU-055}}) rather than by any failure of the student board. The logical resolution, a prompt ratification meeting, would preserve all organizational decisions while restoring procedural regularity. Ratification should be treated as ministerial rather than as an opportunity to revisit organizational decisions.

<span id="HU-194"></span>